Incoming loans policy
The Art Gallery of New South Wales developed out of the New South Wales Academy of Art, established in Sydney on 24 April 1871. It was firmly founded on 19th-century ideals of public education and cultural enrichment. The Gallery and its functions are determined by the Art Gallery of New South Wales Act 1980. The principal objectives of the Art Gallery of New South Wales Trust, outlined in section 7 of the Act, are to develop and maintain a collection of works of art and to propagate and increase the knowledge and appreciation of art. Facilitating access to and appreciation of art through an active and soundly managed incoming Loans program supports the latter objective.
Incoming loans provide access to a diverse array of artworks not represented in the Gallery collection, thereby enhancing the academic, educational and economic potential of the Gallery’s exhibition program. Incoming loans also provide important opportunities for the Gallery to engage in scholarly or professional research, or other projects or undertakings related to works of art, that may contribute significantly to the Gallery’s broader functions.
Incoming loans are assessed and approved in accordance with the powers afforded to the Gallery under the Act and this occurs within an accepted approval and management framework. Exhibition loans are approved at the exhibitions approval meetings by the director, deputy director and senior curator. Long-term loans are approved by the Acquisitions and Loans Committee. The Gallery negotiates and manages incoming loans on terms that are ethical, honourable, responsible and transparent to public scrutiny, thereby maintaining its standing and reputation for excellence and integrity in the public and museum communities, both nationally and internationally. This policy sets out the principles the Gallery will adopt and factors it will consider when assessing, approving and facilitating incoming loans. For the purposes of this policy, incoming loans include loans to the Gallery’s collection, as well as temporary and touring exhibitions.
This policy is established by the director and approved by the Board of Trustees pursuant to the Act.
The objectives of the policy are to:
a. ensure that the Gallery manages and negotiates incoming loans on terms that are ethical, honourable, responsible, sustainable and visible to public scrutiny
b. maintain and promote the Gallery’s standing and reputation for excellence in the public and museum community both nationally and internationally.
These objectives are to be achieved by ensuring that the Gallery:
a. undertakes only those incoming loans that are appropriate to its status and function in all circumstances
b. demonstrates best practice in the risk management of potential and actual incoming loans
c. avoids any act or omission that may attract legal liability, involve the Gallery in civil or criminal proceedings, or otherwise compromise the Gallery’s position and reputation for integrity in public administration.
This policy applies to all activities relating to the incoming loan of works of art. Nothing in this policy detracts from the terms of any loan agreement to which the Gallery is a party.
In this policy:
- Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander art means artwork by an Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander artist or containing Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander themes or content. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander art is defined in accordance with the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Engagement Policy.
- Acquisitions and Loans Committee means the Board of Trustees sub-committee established to review and confirm the acquisition of artworks and the deaccessioning of artworks from the collection, as well as reviewing and approving requests for outgoing loans and long-term incoming loans from the collection in accordance with the Art Gallery of New South Wales Trust – Acquisitions and Loans Committee Charter.
- Act means the Art Gallery of New South Wales Act 1980.
- Approved borrowing institution means an institution approved by the Minister for the Arts, or the Minister’s delegate, under Part 3 of the Protection of Cultural Objects on Loan Act 2013.
- Collection means works of art in various media that are Gallery property and have been formally accessioned. The collection also includes other material acquired and accessioned by the Gallery for the purpose of research and enhancement of the collection, including the National Art Archive and study collection.
- National Art Archive collection means the sum of the institutional archive and the collected archives held by the Art Gallery of New South Wales.
- Study collection comprises works of art designated for the purpose of study or research that support or relate to works of art or artists in the collection. The study collection is a sub-category of the collection and works are accessioned.
- Collection exhibition means an exhibition of works of art that is largely drawn from the Gallery’s collection and may include incoming loans and/or commissions, in accordance with the Exhibitions Development Policy.
- Director means the director of the Art Gallery of New South Wales.
- Due diligence means the thorough assessment of an artwork to evaluate its authenticity, ownership and provenance and to identify and assess any gaps in the provenance.
- Exhibition Executive means the management committee established to approve temporary, collection and touring exhibitions and is defined in accordance with the Exhibitions Development Policy.
- Exhibition program means the forward program and schedule of temporary, collection and touring exhibitions, in accordance with the Exhibitions Development Policy.
- Gallery means the Art Gallery of New South Wales.
- Incoming loan means any contracted arrangement for the transfer of possession of an artwork or other material to the Gallery on a temporary basis under which the transferor grants a temporary right of possession to the Gallery. It therefore includes loans in the strict legal sense of gratuitous bailments, bailments that arise from contracts that expressly benefit both the Gallery and the party transferring possession and other sharing arrangements, such as a scheduled rotation of possession among co-owners. The terms lender, borrower, lending and borrowing and loan and all related or derivative terms are to be construed in the context of this definition and unless otherwise specified, references to incoming loan or any related terms may apply to proposed, contemplated, potential, approved or realised loan arrangements. The terms do not apply to transfers of possession to the Gallery where the Gallery is the sole owner of the object and retains the sole right of possession.
- Incoming loan for temporary exhibition means an incoming loan made for a finite period for the primary purpose of display at the Gallery venue or in a touring exhibition. In the context of this phrase, ‘temporary exhibition’ has a meaning distinct from its definition in the Exhibitions Development Policy.
- Incoming loan to the collection means an incoming loan made for the purpose of display, research or other purposes associated directly with the Gallery’s collection, including but not exclusive to exhibition.
- International in relation to a loan means any loan arrangements pursuant to which an artwork enters Australia from a country outside Australia with the consent of a party ordinarily resident or incorporated outside Australia who grants a temporary right of possession to the artwork(s) to the Gallery for a specified period.
- Loan agreement means a formal, legally binding written contract between the lender, who may be the owner of the artwork(s) subject to the loan or their agent, and the Gallery as borrower, specifying the artwork(s) and outlining the conditions and terms of the loan and the responsibilities of each party.
- Owner means the party or parties who lawfully possess title to the artwork.
- PCOL means Protection of Cultural Objects on Loan and is used in this policy in reference to the Protection of Cultural Objects on Loan Act 2013, Protection of Cultural Objects on Loan Regulation 2014 and Protection of Cultural Objects on Loan Scheme.
- Provenance means the history of ownership of an item from the time of its discovery or creation to the present day, from which authenticity and ownership is determined.
- Temporary exhibition means an exhibition of works of art that may include works drawn from the collection, incoming loans and/or commissions and is defined in accordance with the Exhibitions Development Policy. When used in the context of the whole phrase ‘incoming loan for temporary exhibition,’ this term has a different meaning.
- Title means the legal right to ownership of property.
- Touring exhibition means an exhibition of art that may include works drawn from the collection, incoming loans and/or commissions that the Gallery tours to other venues, in accordance with the Exhibitions Development Policy.
- Trustee means a member of the Board of Trustees of the Art Gallery of New South Wales.
Incoming loans are critical to the Gallery’s capacity to realise its temporary exhibition program, as well as contributing significantly to the collection and touring exhibition programs and providing access to works of art for the purposes of study and research. Incoming loans provide access to an array of artworks not represented in the collection, thereby enhancing the academic, educational and economic potential of the Gallery’s exhibition program.
The Gallery will only undertake those incoming loans that are appropriate to its status, function and legal and ethical obligations in all circumstances. The Gallery will demonstrate best practice in the risk management of incoming loans. In negotiating and managing loans, the Gallery will seek to avoid any act or omission that attracts legal liability, involves the Gallery in civil or criminal proceedings, or otherwise compromises the Gallery’s position and reputation for integrity in public administration.
The Gallery will only borrow artworks where it is confident that:
a. the lender is reputable
b. the owner(s) hold valid title to the work
c. where the lender is not the sole owner, the lender has the legal authority to enter into the loan either:
i. on behalf of the owner and/or co-owners as an agent or representative
ii. as the party who would reasonably be expected to have possession, custody or control of the artwork for the period of the loan, were that arrangement not in place.
d. the works have not been illegally exported from the country of origin or any intermediary countries and relevant export licenses and permits have or will be obtained for export from the country from which they will be exported
e. the import of the works into Australia doesn’t contravene Australian import restrictions, or international treaties or conventions to which Australia is a party or signatory
f. the works have not been obtained through illicit or unauthorised means
g. there are no current or outstanding third-party claims on the works.
The Gallery recognises the UNESCO Convention on the Means of Prohibiting and Preventing the Illicit Import, Export and Transfer of Ownership of Cultural Property 1970 and acknowledges that Australia is a signatory to the Convention. The Gallery also recognises and is bound by the terms of the Protection of Movable Cultural Heritage Act 1986, the PCOL Act, and PCOL Regulation and is guided by the ICOM Code of Ethics for Museums, Museums Australia Code of Ethics, and the Australian best practice guide to collecting cultural material.
The Gallery will remain aware of and vigilant to all risks of legal and ethical controversy that may arise in connection with incoming loans and will respond in a timely manner to notice of matters that bear upon the legal, ethical and social propriety of a loan.
The Gallery recognises that the owner of a work may elect to have the loan negotiated and managed on their behalf by an agent or third party or may elect to remain anonymous. In such instances, the identity of the owner must be made known to the Gallery and documented in the loan agreement. With the exception of this requirement and to the extent that it is able to do so within legislative and policy parameters, the Gallery will comply with this request.
The Gallery will borrow works for a fixed period only, which will be agreed between all parties and which can be extended by mutual agreement. Works of art will not be accepted for loan for an indefinite period. The Gallery will return loans to the original place of dispatch unless negotiated prior to agreeing to the loan.
The Gallery will exercise the same standard of care for works of art on incoming loan as it does for its own collection in accordance with established procedures and professional museum standards.
On occasion, the Gallery may hold works in trust for a brief period for another museum or gallery or in accordance with statutory requirements. For the purposes of this policy, these circumstances do not constitute incoming loans and will be considered custodial arrangements, managed in accordance with established procedures and the Collections Management Policy.
6.2 Approval of incoming loans
All proposed incoming loans for temporary or touring exhibition must be approved by the director or her/his delegate. Loans will be approved at the meetings of the Exhibition Executive, in accordance with the Exhibitions Development Policy and Provenance and Due Diligence Research Policy. The decisions of the Exhibition Executive will be minuted.
All incoming loans for purposes other than temporary or touring exhibition will be reviewed by the Acquisitions and Loans Committee. The decisions of the Acquisitions and Loans Committee will be minuted and ratified at the subsequent meeting of the Board of Trustees.
Once approved by the relevant authority, incoming loans for temporary and touring exhibition will be requested in writing from the lender by the director.
In deciding whether to approve an incoming loan, consideration will be given to:
a. the Act
b. the terms of this policy
c. the findings of provenance and due diligence investigations, conducted in accordance with the Provenance and Due Diligence Research Procedures
d. outcomes and recommendations arising from any community consultations.
The grounds for approval of any incoming loans that do not accord with the considerations outlined in this policy will be minuted by the delegated authority.
6.3 Factors to be considered in the assessment of incoming loans
6.3.1 Ethics, public accountability and risk management
When considering an artwork for incoming loan, the Gallery will:
a. practice and be prepared to show that it has practiced high standards of due diligence
b. seek to establish by all reasonable means all accessible information on the provenance, legal and ethical status and general legitimacy of the work and on the legitimate interests of third parties
c. base the decision whether to borrow, and the terms on which incoming loans are entered into, on a thorough and conscientious appraisal and risk assessment of the information obtained
d. maintain thorough records of the process of incoming loan proposal, investigation and decision-making.
The Gallery will not accept an incoming loan on terms that require it to:
a. suppress reasonable misgivings about the artwork or transact on the basis of a flawed provenance
b. compromise its standing, integrity or freedom to act conscionably
c. act in any other manner contrary to the dictates of conscience and the public interest.
6.3.2 Provenance and due diligence
In determining whether to enter into an incoming loan, the Gallery will evaluate the available provenance information and undertake due diligence to enable it to make an informed assessment. In accordance with the Exhibitions Development Policy and Provenance and Due Diligence Research Policy, the following staff members will assess provenance and determine requirements for further investigation before approving to proceed with the loan:
a. Incoming loans for temporary or touring exhibitions – the director or her/his delegate, in consultation with the Exhibition Executive
b. Incoming loans to the collection and for other purposes – the director or her/his delegate, in consultation with the head curator and deputy director.
Investigation, risk assessment and decision-making will be undertaken and documented in accordance with the Provenance and Due Diligence Research Procedures.
When undertaking an incoming loan, the Gallery will require the lender to provide warranties and indemnities regarding their account of provenance, ownership and/or possession.
After undertaking due diligence and determining to proceed with an incoming loan, if information emerges during the course of the negotiation or conduct of the loan that has the potential to expose the Gallery to legal entanglement or to render the loan ethically contentious, further investigation and risk assessment will be undertaken in accordance with Provenance and Due Diligence Research Policy and Procedures.
6.3.3 Permits, approvals and reporting
The Gallery will act in compliance with all administrative and legal processes in place at an international, national and state level and will obtain all necessary permits or approvals and comply with all other reporting and accountability requirements in relation to the import and export of materials to Australia and movement of materials domestically.
6.3.4 Conflicts of interest: staff and trustees
Unless in exceptional circumstances, works of art in the private collections of Gallery staff will not be accepted for incoming loan.
Gallery staff and members of the Board of Trustees or Acquisitions and Loans Committee must declare any conflict of interest in an incoming loan. The declared conflict will be minuted by the relevant committee or board. Trustees and employees must exclude themselves from any discussion or decision by the Exhibition Executive, Acquisitions and Loans Committee and/or Board of Trustees in relation to an incoming loan in which they have an interest and this will be minuted.
All incoming loans from the private collections of Trustees or members of Board of Trustee sub-committees or Gallery staff must be publicly acknowledged as being from a ‘private collection’.
6.3.5 Repository of last resort
The Gallery recognises that there may be circumstances in which it will take possession of works that do not conform to the provenance and title standards outlined in this policy due to ethical, cultural or legal considerations. This includes circumstances in which there is a significant risk of damage, loss or destruction of the work if the Gallery fails to act; on the request of Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander communities or other traditional owners; or where the Gallery is fulfilling a statutory or legal requirement to do so. Such situations will usually be administered as incoming loans in accordance with this policy, or as custodial arrangements in accordance with the Collections Management Policy.
In considering the incoming loan of such works, the Gallery will consult with representatives of appropriate communities or groups, the professional museum community and/or relevant governments and will be guided in particular by the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Engagement Policy regarding community consultation processes. The Gallery will enter into such arrangements on the basis of sound, considered professional and ethical judgements. Such loans will be undertaken only in specific circumstances and the Gallery will only enter into such arrangements in instances where the works of art are not being borrowed primarily for temporary exhibition purposes.
Such loans will be assessed and approved in accordance with this policy. The basis for the decision and any variations to the terms of the standard loan agreement will be documented in accordance with this policy and associated Incoming Loans Procedures.
6.4 Additional considerations for incoming loans for temporary exhibition
Where relevant, consultation with appropriate individuals, groups, communities or statutory bodies will be undertaken as part of the assessment for incoming loans for temporary and touring exhibitions. Consultations will inform the decision-making as to whether the Gallery will proceed with a proposed loan.
The Gallery will undertake consultation where the work:
a. relates to or holds particular significance for an individual, group or community in Australia
b. was created by an Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander artist, contains Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander themes or content, or relates to an Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander person or community
c. is a document or record that may be relevant to a state, territory or national archive or government records office.
The Gallery is committed to the principle that consultation facilitates the establishment and strengthening of the Gallery’s relationships with its various communities. Accordingly, consultation will be undertaken in a manner that is both outcomes-focused in relation to the incoming loan in question and meaningful in the longer-term. Consultations will be conducted in an open, ethical, transparent and accountable manner, recognising at all times the cultural, social, spiritual and linguistic diversity of the individuals and communities involved. Consultations will be structured and undertaken in a manner consistent with the Incoming Loans Procedures and the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Engagement Procedures.
The Gallery will ensure an appropriate amount of time is allocated for consultation and further follow-up and will ensure that all parties are aware of the timeframe for consultation and decision-making about whether and on what terms the incoming loan will proceed.
Where relevant, consultation will be undertaken for works proposed for incoming loan for temporary and touring exhibitions on each occasion of loan, irrespective of whether the work has been previously borrowed.
6.5 Loan Agreements: Formalising Approved Incoming Loans
Following Gallery approval to proceed with an incoming loan, if the proposed lender agrees in principle to the loan, the exhibition registration team (incoming loans for temporary exhibition) or collection registration team (all other incoming loans) will thereupon assume responsibility for negotiation and loan arrangements.
In consultation with the lender, a member of the exhibition registration team or collection registration team will determine the identity of the party responsible for issuing the loan agreement and on whose terms the loan will be concluded. Where the Gallery is responsible for issuing the loan agreement, incoming loans are concluded using the Gallery’s incoming loan agreement which outlines standard terms, amended by special negotiation when so required, in accordance with the Incoming Loans Procedures. Where the lender’s loan agreement is used, the conditions will be assessed to ensure they are consistent with the terms outlined in this policy and the Gallery’s incoming loan agreement. Where necessary, amended or additional clauses to the lender’s agreement will be negotiated.
Loan agreements for incoming loans for temporary exhibitions, including touring exhibitions, are approved and endorsed under the delegated authority of the director by the manager of exhibition loans and touring and witnessed by the relevant exhibition registrars. Loan agreements for incoming loans for all other purposes, including incoming loans to the collection are approved and endorsed under the delegated authority of the director by the head curator.
6.6 Transparency and Accountability
6.6.1 Publication of incoming loans
In addition to publication requirements specific to incoming loans protected under the terms of the PCOL Act, the director will ensure that a list of all incoming loans to the collection is published in the Gallery’s annual report.
The Gallery may publish or make available a printed or online catalogue or other document for each exhibition listing the artworks that are included in the exhibition.
6.6.2 Record keeping
In accordance with the Record Keeping Policy and established procedures, staff will maintain records (paper based and/or electronic) for each incoming loan, including proposed incoming loans that are not approved, documenting relevant information and decision-making.
6.6.3 Internal audit and review cycle
The director will ensure that compliance with this policy is assessed as part of the Gallery’s audit program. The policy will be reviewed by the Board of Trustees on a regular basis in accordance with the Gallery’s audit program.
6.6.4 Staff obligations
Gallery staff involved in the assessment, approval and administration of incoming loans are bound by the Gallery’s Code of Ethics and Conduct and other relevant Gallery policies, including, but not limited to, the Conflict of Interest Policy, Gifts and Benefits Policy, Fraud Control Policy and Record Keeping Policy.
7. Responsibilities and compliance
7.1 Board of Trustees and Acquisitions and Loans Sub Committee
The Board of Trustees is responsible for approving the long-term loan of artworks, either directly or by delegation to the director subject to cases where ministerial approval is required.
The Acquisitions and Loans Committee is responsible for monitoring and reviewing all aspects of the loans processes of the Gallery and making recommendations to the Board of Trustees in this regard.
7.2 Executive and staff
The director and deputy director are responsible for ensuring that the process and documentation relating to loans conform to all Gallery policies and that Gallery staff understand and comply with the policies.
8. Related documents, legislation and useful links
8.1 Gallery policies
- Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Engagement Policy
- Collection Management Policy 2019 (in review)
- Conflict of Interest Policy
- Copyright and Image Reproduction Policy
- Exhibitions Development Policy
- Fraud Control Policy
- Gifts and Benefits Policy
- Provenance and Due Diligence Research Policy
- Record Keeping Policy
8.2 Guidelines, procedures and associated documents
8.2.1 Gallery guidelines, procedures and associated documents
- Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Engagement Procedures
- Acquisitions and Loans Committee Charter
- Artwork Claims and Inquiries Handling Procedures
- Code of Ethics and Conduct
- Incoming Loans Procedures
- Provenance and Due Diligence Research Procedures
- Risk Management – Statement of Intent
8.2.2 National and international guidelines, procedures and associated documents
- Australian Government, Attorney General’s Department, Ministry for the Arts, Australian best practice guide to collecting cultural material, 2015
- Australian Government, Attorney General’s Department, Ministry for the Arts, Protection of cultural objects on loan: scheme guidelines, 2014
- Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES), 1973, as amended 1979 and 1983
- ICOM, Code of Ethics for Museums, 2017
- ICOM, International Observatory on Illicit Traffic in Cultural Goods
- ICOM, Red Lists of cultural objects at risk
- Museums Australia, Continuing cultures, ongoing responsibilities, 2005
- Pacific Islands Museums Association, Code of Ethics for Pacific Museums and Cultural Centres, 2006
- Unidroit, Convention on Stolen or Illegally Exported Cultural Objects, 1995
- UNESCO, Convention on the Means of Prohibiting and Preventing the Illicit Import, Export and Transfer of Ownership of Cultural Property, 1970
- UNESCO, Database of National Cultural Heritage Laws
- UNESCO, The Hague Convention for the Protection of Cultural Property in the Event of Armed Conflict, 1954, First Protocol, 1954 and Second Protocol, 1999
8.3.1 Commonwealth of Australia
- Crimes Act 1914
- Customs Act 1901
- Personal Properties Securities Act 2009
- Proceeds of Crime Act 2002
- Protection of Cultural Objects on Loan Act 2013
- Protection of Cultural Objects on Loan Regulation 2014
- Protection of Movable Cultural Heritage Act 1986
- Protection of Movable Cultural Heritage Regulation 2018
- Biosecurity Act 2015
- Environmental Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999
8.3.2 New South Wales
- Art Gallery of New South Wales Act 1980
- Government Information (Public Access) Act 2009
- Privacy and Personal Information Protection Act 1998
- Public Finance and Audit Act 1983. Parts that remain to be renamed Government Sector Audit Act 1983
- Public Finance and Audit Regulation 2015
- Government Sector Finance Act 2018
- State Records Act 1998
- Uncollected Goods Act 1995
This policy is also informed by the traditions and precedents set since the establishment of the Gallery.